Les writes:
On Thu, 2007-05-10 at 18:20 -0400, Sam Varshavchik wrote:Intel video is more than enough to get you reasonable 3D eye candy, and their hardware will get better over time. Going with Nvidia today may give you short term benefits, but that will come at the expense of long term goals.Hi, Sam, Intel certainly does create lots of great devices. I have used morethan a few, and overall thought they were good. However Intel has always been weak at vector and matrix processors.This is the area of AMD, Zilog, and a few speciality houses.
Companies tend to channel marketing, hiring and retention efforts on
their core business, thus opening up to the relatively niche business
such as vector processing and video graphics tends to be further down on
the corporate teat, impacting growth potential, and inventiveness, and
even inhibiting hiring of the "new kids" with radical ideas on these
areas.
Both AMD and Nvidia simply have a huge head start on Intel in this area. Intel is a relative newcomer, while both ATI (now AMD), and Nvidia have been in this game for years, and have opened up a huge lead on Intel.
But this is just a matter of time. Intel has as much resources and brainpower as ATI, or Nvidia, if not more. I'm expecting that over the next 3-5 years, if they persist on their current course, their video hardware will close the gap and will be in the same general ballpark. They do not need to technically outperform the rest of the crowd, they just need to be in the same ballpark.
Consider that, as well as:1) The Centrino chipset is, for all practical matters, free. You need to grab the right firmware package from Livna, but once you do that, the existing free kernel drivers wake up and do their job. Maybe some day someone will figure out how to have the firmware image file included in Debian or Fedora, but for all practical matters it makes very little difference today.
2) ivtv/video4linux recently received permission from a certain MPEG encoder card manufacturer to freely redistribute firmware files for their boards. I've got a box in the basement running MythTV on FC6, happily filling up its hard drive. Replacing its current video card with some heat generator from Nvidia or ATI, and then polluting it with their blobs would feel so… dirty.
Attachment:
pgpsCp6wYJJRt.pgp
Description: PGP signature
