Re: Sandisk Compact Flash

[somshekar.c.kadam@in.abb.com]

Hi David ,

    On my controller CF INPACK pin is connected to 3.3v.  so Comapct flash
with DMA capabilty will not be supported , i understood this .
but i did not undesrtand why only PIO mode 1 is supported is it , why not
PIO mode 4 , is it a limitation of pcmcia driver , correct me if i am wrong

Thanks In Advance
Somshekar



                                                                                                     
 (Embedded     David Hinds <dhinds@sonic.net>                                                        
 image moved   07/15/2005 10:51 AM                                                                   
 to file:                                                                                            
 pic05705.pcx)                                                                                       
                                                                                                     
                                                                                                     



To:    somshekar.c.kadam@in.abb.com
cc:    linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org
Subject:    Re: Sandisk Compact Flash

Security Level:?              Internal

On Wed, Jul 13, 2005 at 07:04:38PM +0530, somshekar.c.kadam@in.abb.com
wrote:
>
> I ma newbie to compactflash driver , I am using mpc862 PPC processor
> on my custom board having 64mb ram running linuxppc-2.4.18 kernel .
> i am using Sandisk Extreme CF 1GB which is 133x high speed, but
> found the performance with other kingston 1GB CF with slower speed ,
> is both same , CF is implemented on pcmcia port , i am not sure what
> is the mode set for transfer , Feature set command is used in which
> it sets the PIO mode or Multiword DMA transfer mode by specifying
> its value in Sector count register , i am not able to understand in
> linux kernel ide driver where this is set , is it by default set ,
> this mode is set or we need to set it , i think we should assign
> this value , right now i am not able to trace this in my code.  ,

All Compact Flash cards, in 16-bit PCMCIA card readers, operate in PIO
mode 1 (polled IO, no DMA), which means you will get only about 1
MB/sec regardless of the card's claimed tranfer speed.  Some cameras
also only support this mode; others will run CF cars in "TrueIDE"
mode, which is required to use the DMA transfer modes.

There are high performance CF card readers that can use TrueIDE mode:
both CardBus ones and Firewire ones.  For example:

http://www.dpreview.com/news/0310/03102103delkincardbustest.asp

It sounds like your card reader is one of the slow 16-bit ones.

-- Dave

Attachment: pic05705.pcx
Description: Binary data