Mike McCarty wrote:
Robin Laing wrote:
Mike McCarty wrote:
Robin Laing wrote:
I label all my devices when I format them. They then mount as
/media/{label name}.
You label your cameras and printers when you format them?
Oops, I should have said cards and hard drives. All my USB devices
are either cards or hard drives. I take the card out of my camera as
it doesn't drain the batteries then.
If you persisted, I was going to ask you about your keyboard and mouse.
:-)
My mouse and keyboard are not usb so it wouldn't have worked. Ha Ha.
Furthermore, my question also involved (if you read my original
message) ethernet cards.
I trow you don't label your ethernet cards when you format them. :-)
[snip]
That doesn't fix the fact that /etc/fstab has to point to a device
name, and that is a moving target. Sometimes I have to mount /dev/sda1
and sometimes /dev/sde1 and sometimes /dev/sdf1 for the same physical
device.
Mike
I look at the mount point to work with. In my case, all my cards or
You didn't address my statement, though. Currently, my fstab has to
have the mount parameters in it, and that has to point to a node in
/dev. The node I need to use changes based on the phase of the moon,
and other things I don't have control over. So each time I boot, I have
to edit /etc/fstab to fiddle it up to correspond to how the machine
came up. This is true even if I use the mount point when mounting
(which I normally do), rather than the device node (which I rarely
do).
In my case, hal sets the fstab. There are no entries for /dev/sd(x) in
my work computer. At least not until I plug in my USB stick.
This is the tail of my /etc/fstab at work before I insert my stick.
/dev/hdc /media/cdrecorder auto
pamconsole,exec,noauto,managed 0 0
-----
Here it is after.
/dev/hdc /media/cdrecorder auto
pamconsole,exec,noauto,managed 0 0
/dev/sda1 /media/Robin_Laing vfat
pamconsole,exec,noauto,fscontext=system_u:object_r:removable_t,utf8,managed
0 0
-----
And external hard drive.
/dev/hdc /media/cdrecorder auto
pamconsole,exec,noauto,managed 0 0
/dev/sda1 /media/MES_R_LAING vfat
pamconsole,exec,noauto,fscontext=system_u:object_r:removable_t,utf8,managed
0 0
------
External HD and Stick
/dev/sda1 /media/MES_R_LAING vfat
pamconsole,exec,noauto,fscontext=system_u:object_r:removable_t,utf8,managed
0 0
/dev/sdb1 /media/Robin_Laing vfat
pamconsole,exec,noauto,fscontext=system_u:object_r:removable_t,utf8,managed
0 0
------
It is done automatically.
HD's will mount under media with the name they are labeled with. Thus
my work HD comes up with my section and my name every time.
My work thumb drives do the same thing.
You seem to be talking about a separate topic, altogether, now.
I asked about a unified approach to having persistent naming of
devices under Linux. You appear not to be discussing this topic.
You seem to be discussing having persistent naming for file
systems, for which so far I have had no need.
It appears that there may be a partial solution for disc or
disc emulating devices with udev, the jury is still out on
that one for me, especially as I haven't investigated the
controversy that seems to surround it. But I'm grateful
for the pointer to udev, and intend to investigate it further.
It appears to address somewhat the issue of printers, as
well. It does not seem to address ethernet ports.
The overall topic seems not to have been addressed at all,
AFAICT.Now my ethernet ports (embeded on mother board) seem to be set in /etc/sysconfig/ or someplace. I don't remember. I have only had one issue with ethernet since putting FC4 on my computer. See what happens when FC6 gets installed.
Mike
Now my ethernet ports (embedded on mother board) seem to be set in
/etc/sysconfig/ or someplace. I don't remember. I have only had one
issue with ethernet since putting FC4 on my computer. See what happens
when FC6 gets installed. I only use the one port.
I find it hard to have a default name for every device as that would
entail millions of names to deal with duplication of devices on the same
machine. If the device is identified, then that should be enough. Let
the user customize.
I would have to look at my USB printer at home. The printer installer
created all the device info for that. It would have been nicer if cups
would have handled that but that is life. No real difference than the
last time I had to install a printer on Windows.
I will say that in the past I made the mistake of messing with the
/etc/fstab file only to be screwed up. I have also found that the
mounting of my USB devices changes depending on the port used or the
order that they are plugged in. But because things have just worked
with the labels, it hasn't been a problem so I have not looked back
since trying to get hotplug to work.
I am no wizard with this and you are now asking me questions beyond my
experience.
Good luck.
--
Robin Laing
