Re: Gnome vs KDE

[Arthur Pemberton <dalive@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

David Curry wrote:

> Rahul Sundaram wrote:
>
> > Hi
> >  
> >
> >
> >  
> >
> > > I'm quite certain that a GNOME desktop as delivered by GNOME and a KDE
> > > desktop as delivered by KDE - without Red Hat / Fedora alterations 
> > > might
> > > demonstrate some of the differences more readily.
> > >   
> >
> >
> > not true anymore. both kde and gnome are pretty close to the upstream
> > versions in fedora
> >
> >  
> FWIW, the CD drive mounting problem is not confined to Fedora Core 
> distribution.  In FC2 using a KDE 3.2 variant, I simply cannot mount 
> either of my CD-ROM or CD-RW drives.  A few days ago, running a Gnome 
> desktop I downloaded and burned a LiveCD distribution named 
> SimplyMEPIS which uses KDE3.3 on top of a Debian distribution.
> I was able to boot from the LiveCd in the CD-RW drive without any 
> problems but could not then mount the CD-ROM.  One conspicuous 
> difference between the KDE desktop MEPIS was the placement of CD drive 
> icons on the desktop compared to having CD drives buried in submenus 
> on the KDE (and Gnome) desktop(s) in FC2.
I'd like to hope that everyone complaining of this issue has filed 
appropriate bug reports.