Re: AGPGart / AMD K7

["Preston A. Elder" <prez@goth.net>]

Final followup,

If I compile EDAC out of the kernel completely, everything works now.

This should be resolved though.
1) dd.c should produce some kind of warning when it wants to assign a
driver to a device, but it can't because a driver is already assigned to
a device

ie. change:
      if (!dev->driver)
          driver_probe_device(drv, dev);
to:
      if (!dev->driver)
          driver_probe_device(drv, dev);
      else
          printk(KERN_WARNING "__driver_attach (%s): alreay registered
with driver %s\n",
             dev->bus_id, dev->driver->name);

2) Possibly a device should be able to have more than one driver
associated with it - so the AGP driver and EDAC could both use the
device in question here (though this would probably be a sizable change).

Either way, at least I found the culprit :)

PreZ :)

Preston A. Elder wrote:
> Dave Jones wrote:
>   
>> On Fri, Apr 20, 2007 at 04:22:06PM -0400, Preston A. Elder wrote:
>>  > Dave, Greg,
>>  > 
>>  > Here is the trace with 2.6.20.6
>>  > 
>>  > I added back in my trace code, as you see.  As you can also see,
>>  > agp_amdk7_probe is still not called.
>>
>> Try looking down in __driver_attach()
>> The fact that we're not calling the ->probe function is quite bizarre.
>>
>> It could be this in __driver_attach
>>
>>         if (!dev->driver)
>>                 driver_probe_device(drv, dev);
>>
>> Though that'd be odd.
>>
>> Putting a #define DEBUG 1 in drivers/base/dd.c may also yield some clues.
>>
>> 	Dave
>>
>>   
>>     
> OK, I found it!
>
> Here is more trace:
> Linux agpgart interface v0.101 (c) Dave Jones
> agp_amdk7_init: In function
> agp_amdk7_init: Before pci_register_driver
> __pci_register_driver: In Function (driver = agpgart-amdk7, multithread = 0)
> __pci_register_driver: Before Spinlock
> __pci_register_driver: Before Init List Head
> __pci_register_driver: Before driver_register
> bus_add_driver: In Function (c0492920)
> bus_add_driver: Before kobject_set_name
> bus_add_driver: error = 0
> bus_add_driver: Before kobject_register
> bus_add_driver: error = 0
> bus_add_driver: Before driver_attach
> __driver_attach (0000:00:00.0,1): Before Down (parent) (c21c8600)
> __driver_attach (0000:00:00.0, 1): Before Down
> __driver_attach (0000:00:00.0, 1): Before Probe Device (c049fe54)
> __driver_attach (0000:00:00.0, 1): alreay registered with driver amd76x_edac
> __driver_attach (0000:00:00.0, 1): Before Up
> __driver_attach (0000:00:00.0, 1): Before Up (parent) (c21c8600)
> __driver_attach (0000:00:00.0, 1): Returning 0
> bus_add_driver: error = 0
> bus_add_driver: Before klist_add_tail
> bus_add_driver: Before module_add_driver
> bus_add_driver: Before driver_add_attrs
> bus_add_driver: error = 0
> bus_add_driver: Before add_bind_files
> bus_add_driver: error = 0
> bus_add_driver: Returning 0
> __pci_register_driver: error = 0
> __pci_register_driver: Before pci_create_newid_file
> __pci_register_driver: error = 0
> __pci_register_driver: Returning 0
>
> I snipped some since __driver_attach is called many times.
>
> But the long and short is that 00:00:00 is already associated with the
> 'amd76x_edac' driver, and as such will not call the agp probe call. 
> What is this edac, btw?
>
> PreZ :)
>
>
>
>   

-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/