Wade, I'm just getting caught up on my email, and came across this thread. I don't see anything wrong with what you did. I've taught RH to complete newbies (just learned how to double-click in the last 6 months). I do give them much more detail, but they are a known quantity. This mailing list is not. The people on the list are self-starters, looking for some direction. If the person needed more detail, they will ask. Some people are hungry learners, and want to figure out things on their own. It's a bit like not wanting to know the ending of the movie. -Eric Schroeder CCNA, RHCE(809003614507937) -----Original Message----- From: fedora-list-admin@xxxxxxxxxx [mailto:fedora-list-admin@xxxxxxxxxx]On Behalf Of Wade Chandler Sent: Friday, February 27, 2004 9:35 AM To: fedora-list@xxxxxxxxxx Subject: Re: Grub.conf example for anyone interested in dual or in this case tri boot. Alexander Dalloz wrote: > Am Fr, den 27.02.2004 schrieb Harry Putnam um 14:02: > >>Alexander Dalloz <alexander.dalloz@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> writes: >> >> >>>>Wade >>> >>>I feel such an uncommented example file does not help anyone. The one >>>who understands what he sees could have made his grub configuration >>>without such an example. >>> >>>You are welcome with your help Wade, but please be more verbose and >>>explain to people what the settings do and what they mean (not for me). >> >>I heartily disagree with this.... Actual examples are often the MOST >>usefull learning tool. The fact it isn't commented may be slightly >>lamentable but not really a reason to call Wade on the carpet. >> >>What he showed could nearly be cut an pasted for use. That is a good thing. > > > Sorry, you couldn't copy&paste - maybe just the fact as he did not > describe how his harddrive is partitioned and he did not explain to > users what root (hd1,2) and the others would mean and cause. The example > is not self-explanatory. > > Alexander > > Alexander, This is just my opinion. This conversation isn't going anywhere. I just posted my conf file to the list. No need for remarks that aren't going to be very helpful. The file show's a working example. Let's let the users who can't figure it out ask a question about the file when they decide it is useless or not. Deciding for them is nothing shy of holding them back and adding uncertainty to their situation. Users mainly ask is it possible. I have a feeling most people trying to get dual boot to work on a PC are more than capable of understanding something as simple as Grub with a nudge in the right direction. If they are not, they'll ask. I wasn't writing a tutorial. The info file has enough of that. info grub for anyone needing more information. Wade -- fedora-list mailing list fedora-list@xxxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe: http://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-list
