Re: [PATCH] Add __GFP_MOVABLE for callers to flag allocations that may be migrated

[Christoph Lameter <clameter@sgi.com>]

On Mon, 4 Dec 2006, Andrew Morton wrote:

> My concern is that __GFP_MOVABLE is useful for fragmentation-avoidance, but
> useless for memory hot-unplug.  So that if/when hot-unplug comes along
> we'll add more gunk which is a somewhat-superset of the GFP_MOVABLE
> infrastructure, hence we didn't need the GFP_MOVABLE code.  Or something.

It is useless for memory unplug until we implement limits for unmovable 
pages in a zone (per MA_ORDER area? That would fit nicely into the anti 
frag scheme) or until we have logic that makes !GFP_MOVABLE allocations 
fall back to a node that is not removable.

> That depends on how we do hot-unplug, if we do it.  I continue to suspect
> that it'll be done via memory zones: effectively by resurrecting
> GFP_HIGHMEM.  In which case there's little overlap with anti-frag.  (btw, I
> have a suspicion that the most important application of memory hot-unplug
> will be power management: destructively turning off DIMMs).

There are numerous other uses as well (besides DIMM and node unplug):

1. Faulty DIMM isolation
2. Virtual memory managers can reduce memory without resorting to 
   balloons.
3. Physical removal and exchange of memory while a system is running
   (Likely necessary to complement hotplug cpu, cpus usually come
   with memory).

The multi zone approach does not work with NUMA. NUMA only supports a 
single zone for memory policy control etc. Also multiple zones carry with 
it a management overhead that is unnecessary for the MOVABLE/UNMOVABLE
distinction.
 
> perhaps not for the hugetlbpage problem.  Whereas anti-fragmentation adds
> vastly more code, but can address both problems?  Or something.

I'd favor adding full defragmentation.
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/