Reboot rant [was: Re: : [ FC2 ] ::.. NON-CRITICAL config question.]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



Keven Ring wrote:


Hi,
Since you are new to Linux, you might want to run system-config-network and
select the NIC that is configured with DHCP, configure the hostname
manually, and save


Excellent Advice

and reboot.



<rant>

Why oh Why do we have to suggest to people that rebooting will take care of everything.

Folks, just because some major OS must reboot for anything to take effect, does not mean that this is true of Unix in general, to include Linux.

Why I shutdown/reboot unix boxes:
1) I have a new kernel
2) The kernel crashed (ok, this, admitted doesn't happen)
3) Something locked the machine up (kernel, driver, etc)
4) Power/Hardware Failure
5) I take my laptop home
6) I have to run some other OS

Unix machines are generally *not* SINGLE USER MACHINES (there are exceptions, of course!).

IMO, rebooting in most other circumstances (changing network config, etc) means that you just don't know how to solve the problem without rebooting. Personally, I would rather find the "correct, intended" way to solve the problem, rather than resorting to reboots. In the "olden days", it could take HOURS for a system to reboot..... It wasn't something you did for fun...

In the case of a network configuration change, try the following as root (or sudo, if you prefer)
service network stop
service network start


or, if you don't like to type,
service network restart

If you only want to recycle your ethernet hostname,
ifdown eth0
ifup eth0

should work fine. (You may need to restart X, but that is for entirely different reasons).


If you get into the mentality of rebooting like other OS's, then you might as well reboot whenever you install/update something via apt/yum/rpm, or when you compile something, etc.


Perhaps a new menu item in Linux, similar to that in Wine/Crossover Office: Simulate Reboot

</rant>

I seem to recall that the redhat-config-network app. suggests rebooting when changing host names. I haven't used it in a while, so maybe it doesn't anymore? [shrug] Anyway, if it does, then you should send your rant to the redhat-config-network app. developers as well.

--
Mitch Wiedemann
mc^2 Computer Consulting
mc2@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://www.lightlink.com/mc2



[Index of Archives]     [Current Fedora Users]     [Fedora Desktop]     [Fedora SELinux]     [Yosemite News]     [Yosemite Photos]     [KDE Users]     [Fedora Tools]     [Fedora Docs]

  Powered by Linux